For professional managers, 2025 has been a nightmare year of missed opportunity. With only six weeks left, a staggering 78% have been crushed by the S&P 500. This is the worst performance in two decades. But this disaster is not a signal of irrational optimism; it is the clearest sign yet that more gains are likely.
This rally hasn’t been a rising tide lifting all boats; it’s been a three-stock lifeboat. Nvidia (NVDA), Microsoft (MSFT), and Apple (AAPL) have generated the majority of the index’s staggering returns. The vast majority of stocks have simply drifted. This structural narrowness is the trap that captured active managers. Their valuation concerns or diversification mandates forced them to underweight the very stocks that mattered most. Now they are way behind the S&P 500, their benchmark.
While professionals have been sidelined, individual investors are now turning bearish. The AAII Sentiment Survey shows bearish sentiment hovering at 36.3%, significantly above its historical floor of 31%. This is the paradox of 2025: a strong market that almost no one—professional or retail—truly believes in.
The popular perception is that too many investors are optimistic. The opposite is true. Almost nobody believes stocks can keep climbing. And this is the opportunity for investors.
The calendar has become the active manager’s enemy. With only six weeks remaining, the pressure to avoid a “career-risk” year has become immense and mechanical. The need to close the gap suggests a forced stampede of sidelined capital back into the only stocks that have worked: the mega-cap leaders.
This isn’t a measured investment decision; it’s a late-year scramble that will temporarily overwhelm traditional valuation concerns. This performance-chasing mechanism is not a new theory; it is a well-documented short-term pattern.
A Princeton study confirms that following periods of extreme underperformance, managers consistently surge back into market leaders over weeks, not months, fueling a final, surprising leg of the rally.
With the year winding down, professionals will be forced to chase performance. The confluence of widespread professional caution and the inevitable, forced rush for a strong finish will create a powerful, albeit short-lived, late-year surge. Monitor the flow of capital into the market’s leaders now. Position portfolios to capture the final, furious rally driven by those who can no longer afford to be wrong.
For more Markman directly to your inbox subscribe to our Substack. (Its Free).