For a lot of drinkers, tequila still conjures up memories of rushed shots, salt, and a regrettable night. But here’s the truth: good tequila deserves better. The best tequilas — the ones crafted carefully, without additives, and made from fully mature agave — aren’t made for shooting. They’re made for sipping.
Like a fine Scotch or bourbon, a great tequila deserves to be savored: slow, thoughtful, and full of layered, evolving flavors. Whether you prefer a pure, clean blanco or a rich, barrel-aged añejo, sipping tequila opens up an entirely different—and far better—experience with the spirit.
I spoke to bartenders, beverage directors, and agave experts about their favorite tequilas for sipping. Here’s what they recommend—and why these bottles deserve your full attention.
Why Sipping Tequila Is Different
“When choosing to sip on tequila rather than making a cocktail with it, you’re making the conscious effort of wanting to taste the process of tequila distillation,” says Nicolette “Nikki” Bonkowski, Bar Lead at Whiskey Neat in Fort Lauderdale. For Bonkowski, finding a good sipping tequila means starting with quality: “You’ll want to seek out qualities that include 100% agave and additive free.”
She recommends Lalo Blanco, describing it as smooth, balanced, and full of toasted agave sweetness—so much so that “you won’t need or want to add anything to it.”
Chef Richard Sandoval, of Richard Sandoval Hospitality, shares a similar affection for blancos. “I’ve always gravitated toward blancos. They’re the purest expression of agave—the soul of tequila in its most honest form,” he says. Among his favorites are Lalo Tequila and Tequila Deferente. Lalo, he says, “delivers brightness and elegance with each sip,” while Deferente captures the beauty of highland agave, “crisp, floral, and layered with minerality.”
In other words: if you’re new to sipping tequila, a blanco is a pure, honest place to start.
The Appeal of Reposados and Añejos
While blancos show the raw beauty of agave, reposados and añejos offer a deeper, more layered experience—without masking the spirit’s soul.
Reposado means “rested” in Spanish, and these tequilas are aged in oak barrels for anywhere from two months to one year. The aging process softens the fresh, vegetal notes of the agave and adds subtle layers of vanilla, caramel, spice, and sometimes light oak without overpowering the spirit’s natural character.
Añejo tequila, meaning “aged,” is barrel-aged for one to three years, developing a deeper color and richer flavors like toffee, baking spice, roasted agave, and dark chocolate.
Orestes Cruz, bar lead at Palo Santo in Atlanta, recommends Tierra de Ensueño Single Barrel Reposado (Wheated Bourbon Cask) for sipping, describing it as “balanced sipping tequila with apple, cinnamon, oak, toffee, vanilla, and cocoa notes.” He adds, “Tierra de Ensueño has a buttery mouthfeel with a warm baking spice finish. I enjoy this tequila in a glass with a large ice cube.”
For a slightly richer expression, Danny Garcia, Assistant General Manager at Lady Jane in Denver, turns to Wild Common Reposado. “At 43% ABV, it is slightly higher proof than most tequilas on the market, but higher proof doesn’t equate to more burn,” he explains. “The slightly higher proof allows more nuance and flavor to be present and experienced while sipping. For me, this tequila smells of butterscotch and faint tobacco and tastes like spiced caramel.”
If you’re looking for something to impress even the toughest critics, Fortaleza might be the answer. Jordan Joseph, Beverage Director at Crawford Hospitality, compares Fortaleza Anejo to the “Pappy Van Winkle” of tequila: hard to find, highly prized, and worth every drop. “It offers a great balance of Fortaleza’s agave spirit and barrel influence,” he says, with driving flavors like “Werther’s Caramels, white peppercorn, vanilla gelato, and green cardamon.”
Justin Parramore, Beverage Manager at Old Pueblo Cantina in Chicago, champions Fortaleza Reposado for its incredible texture and universal appeal. “There’s a subtle note of sweet spice that balances the savory quality of the cooked agave, and a nice almost oily texture to add some interest to the glass. I’ve never seen this tequila disappoint.”
Hidden Gems for Everyday Sipping
If you’re looking for hidden treasures that sip beautifully without the heavy price tag, the pros have their favorites too.
Augusto Lino, Bar Manager at Noir Bar, recommends La Gritona Reposado, noting that it’s all about balance: “They’re not trying to hide the tequila behind secondary notes from oak barrels; they are simply using the six months of aging to soften the vegetable essence of their original product.” Bonus: it’s a woman-owned, additive-free brand.
Rio Azmee, General Manager at Bar Moga, suggests keeping Herradura Anejo Ultra chilled in the freezer for a smooth sipping experience. “It has flavors of cooked agave, caramel, honey, and toasted almond which makes it perfect for sipping,” he says.
Meanwhile, Alexa Roberson, bartender and beverage manager at C&S Oyster Bar in Atlanta, applauds Inspiro Tequila, praising not only its clean flavor but the fact that it’s woman-owned and additive-free—a meaningful combination for today’s conscientious drinkers.
Special Bottles for the Serious Collector
For those who like their spirits with a little story (and a lot of aging), Fuenteseca offers some of the finest sipping tequilas on the planet.
John Cooper, General Manager at Vagabond DC, swears by the Fuenteseca Reserva Extra Anejo 21 Year, appreciating its complexity: “I enjoy the varying niche notes due to the way it was aged both the barrels and in two different climates which gives it a unique flavor profile.”
For something a little more approachable (but no less extraordinary), Oscar Ramirez of The Hideaway in Beverly Hills recommends the Fuenteseca Reserva 7 Year, calling it “super smooth, full of deep flavor,” and noting, “you can taste how much care went into it. It’s truly a tequila made for sipping, not shooting.”
Other Standouts Worth Savoring
Additional favorites from experts include Don Fulano Blanco, praised by Amber Bruce of The Keefer Bar for its richness and creamy texture despite a slightly higher proof. Amir Babayoff, Bar Director at Ophelia in NYC, agrees, calling Don Fulano “a standout sipping tequila with rich, full-bodied depth and no additives,” layered with notes of “agave, vanilla, tropical fruit, herbs, pepper, and minerals.”
Tequila Ocho Reposado also earns a spot on the list for those who want a softer, lightly aged profile. As JoanRose Caguiat, Director of Beverages at The Ridley House, puts it: “Tequila Ocho Reposado is a standout sipping tequila because it highlights the true essence of agave while layering in subtle oak aging. It’s smooth, vibrant, and lightly sweet, with notes of cooked agave, tropical fruit, and soft spice.”
Even spicier takes on tequila, like Tanteo Chipotle, have their moment. Ivan Vasquez, owner and bar manager at Mayahuel in Queens, calls it “easy and smooth to sip and gives a pleasant chile heat that’s not overwhelming,” noting its mild smokiness adds a unique character to the glass.
This Cinco de Mayo, leave the shot glasses behind. Instead, celebrate with a truly great tequila: one that showcases pure agave flavor, craftsmanship, and complexity.
Whether you choose a bright blanco like Lalo or Don Fulano, a rich reposado like Tierra de Ensueño or Wild Common, or a long-aged beauty like Fuenteseca, one thing is clear: great tequila deserves more than salt and lime. It deserves your full attention.
Because when you sip it slowly, you realize tequila isn’t just a drink—it’s an experience.