The Innovator’s Dilemma
Tesla (TSLA) reported third-quarter financial results last week, and shares traded lower as profits slumped and margins compressed. Look past the weakness. While the current car business struggles with the noise around lost tax credits, investors are missing the crucial signal: Tesla is systematically shedding its identity as a car company.
Investors must look beyond the car sales data. Tesla is not an automotive company like Ford (F) or General Motors (GM). It is an agile firm in constant transition, fundamentally evolving into a robotics company through substantial investments in autonomous driving technology. Traditional competitors are missing this pivot at their peril.
Since being founded in 2003, Tesla has operated under the philosophy of disruptive innovation. This means introducing products that initially underperform established peers but ultimately capture most of the market. Think about how smartphone cameras supplanted digital cameras through sheer utility and evolution.
This situation is perfectly explained by The Innovator’s Dilemma, the 1997 book by Harvard professor Clayton Christensen. He posited that incumbents ignore low-end disruptive innovations until it’s too late. Tesla is the disruptor, reshaping transportation, energy, and robotics while competitors cling to sustaining innovations.
Make no mistake, executives at legacy companies like GM are aware of the ultimate threat posed by Tesla’s Full Self-Driving technology. They simply do not recognize the urgency. GM execs stated last week their “hands-off, eyes-off” product might not arrive until 2028. Tesla offers FSD today.
By delaying a cogent response to FSD, competitors like GM are ensuring Tesla’s victory in the EV transition. The company can pivot completely: autonomous driving transforms the car into the fundamental, data-collecting, road-going robot. This is a big competitive advantage.
This robotic foundation also supports a much larger vision: electrified large trucks, futuristic buses, and the ambitious humanoid robot project that Elon Musk claims will account for 80% of future sales. The transition to a robotics platform is the first step to unlocking massive new markets.
Stop valuing Tesla against legacy automakers. The “unrealistic premium” reflects its status as a disruptive robotics firm, not a car business. Invest accordingly: The smart money looks past Q3 noise and buys the company building the smartphone, not the one refining the digital camera.
For more Markman delivered straight to your inbox every morning, subscribe to my substack here. I promise its profitable, entertaining and sometimes funny.